Four-Point Inspection on an Older Winter Park or Maitland Home: What Insurers Flag Before Closing

Winter Park, Florida

Here is a call that comes up a lot with older homes. A buyer is under contract on a charming older house in Winter Park or Maitland, the home inspection went fine, and then the insurance agent says, “I need a four-point before I can quote it.” A few days later the four-point comes back with a note about the electrical panel or the roof, and suddenly the closing date feels a lot less certain.

The four-point inspection is not a deal killer. It is just the inspection most buyers have never heard of until the week it matters. If you are looking at a house in Orwin Manor, Lakemont, Winter Park Pines, Dommerich Estates or along the older streets off Lake Sybelia, there is a good chance you will need one. Here is what it is, what insurers look at, and how I line it up so it does not blow up a closing.

What a four-point inspection actually is

A four-point inspection is a short, insurance-focused report on four systems: the electrical system, the plumbing, the heating and air conditioning (HVAC), and the roof. It is not a full home inspection. Nobody is testing every outlet or opening every window. The insurer wants to know the age, type and condition of the systems most likely to cause a claim.

Citizens Property Insurance, Florida’s state-backed insurer, spells out its rule plainly on its Inspections page: it requires a four-point inspection for all property owner, dwelling and mobile home applications for properties more than 20 years old. A Florida-licensed inspector checks the electrical system, plumbing, HVAC and roof, and reports the age, type and condition of each. Citizens adds that serious hazards or deficiencies, such as exposed wiring, active leaks or evidence of leaks, should be repaired before an application for coverage is submitted.

Citizens’ FAQ adds that the inspection must be from within the last year, by a verifiable Florida-licensed inspector such as a home inspector or contractor, and that four-points do not apply to tenant or condominium policies.

Private insurance companies set their own underwriting rules. Many ask for a four-point on older houses, but the cutoffs differ, so ask your insurance agent early, in writing, what that carrier needs.

Why it comes up so often in Winter Park and Maitland

Twenty years is not old for a house, but in 2026 it means roughly anything built before about 2006. In Winter Park and Maitland’s established neighborhoods, a lot of houses are well past that mark. Plenty of well-kept, updated houses still fall on the older side of that line, and the form only cares what can be documented.

What the inspector writes down

Citizens’ sample 4-Point Inspection Form (revision Insp4pt 03 25) shows exactly what gets reported. It requires photos of each side of the house, each roof slope, the water heater and the electrical panel with its cover off. Each section asks:

  • Electrical: breakers or fuses, total amps, and whether the amperage is enough for current use. The form asks about cloth wiring, active knob and tube, and branch-circuit aluminum wiring, and any remediation of single-strand aluminum wiring has to be documented separately by a licensed electrician. It also lists hazards such as double taps, exposed wiring and scorching, and records the panel’s age and brand.
  • HVAC: working order, last servicing date, equipment age (with a photo of the dated manufacturer’s plate), and any leaks or blockage at the air handler or drain pan.
  • Plumbing: the water heater’s relief valve, active or prior leaks, whether the pipes are original or re-piped, and the pipe material, including galvanized, cast iron and polybutylene.
  • Roof: the covering, its age and condition, and any visible damage or leaks. Older roofs can trigger a separate roof inspection form, which I cover next.

Notice how much of this is about dates. “Year last updated” appears for the panel, the HVAC and the pipes. That is where most older houses get into trouble. The system may be fine, but if nobody can document when it was replaced, the inspector writes down what he can see, and the underwriter decides what to do with it.

The roof rule that surprises buyers

Roofs get their own attention. According to Citizens, roofs older than 25 years for soft coverings such as shingle, or 50 years for hard coverings such as tile, slate, clay, concrete or metal, need documentation showing at least five years of remaining useful life. A Florida-licensed inspector has to look at the roof for visible damage or deterioration. If the roof has less than five years of useful life left, Citizens requires proof of a full roof replacement before any policy is written. Keep in mind those 25- and 50-year limits are Citizens’ rules. Private insurers set their own roof-age cutoffs, and some are stricter, so ask your insurance agent early what that carrier allows for your roof type.

Florida law also limits how roof age alone can be used. Under section 627.7011(5), Florida Statutes, an insurer may not refuse to issue or renew a homeowner’s policy solely because a roof is less than 15 years old. For a roof that is at least 15 years old, the insurer has to let the homeowner get a roof inspection by an authorized inspector, at the homeowner’s expense, before requiring replacement. And if that inspection shows five years or more of useful life left, the insurer may not refuse coverage solely because of roof age.

Under that same statute, a roof’s age is measured from the last date 100 percent of the roof surface was built or replaced to code. A patch job does not reset the clock. So when a seller says the roof is “newer,” I want the permit and the invoice, not a memory.

Check the permits before the inspector shows up

This is the step that saves the most time. If the house is inside Winter Park city limits, start at the city’s Building and Permitting Services page. The city’s permits search splits records into active permits (2020 to present) and archived permits (before 2020), so search both. A roof, panel change, re-pipe or new AC from 2015 will not show up if you only look at the active list.

A Winter Park or Maitland mailing address does not always mean the city handles the permits. Some houses with those addresses sit in unincorporated Orange or Seminole County, and Maitland has its own building department. Go by the jurisdiction on the property appraiser’s record, not the mailing city. I explain how to check that in What a Winter Park Address Actually Means.

How I time it during a purchase

On a typical Florida contract, the inspection period is short, and the insurance binder is due before closing. I want the four-point information while the buyer can still negotiate. Here is how I usually run it:

  1. Before the offer: ask the listing agent for any existing four-point, wind mitigation report, roof permit and recent invoices.
  2. Day one under contract: call the insurance agent with the address and year built, and ask exactly which inspections that carrier needs.
  3. Schedule the inspections together: many inspectors can do the general home inspection, the four-point and the wind mitigation inspection in one visit. The wind mitigation form is a separate report that can earn insurance credits, so it is worth getting even when it is not required.
  4. Send the four-point to the insurance agent right away, before the inspection period ends, so a problem shows up while there is still time to act.
  5. If something is flagged: ask for a repair by a licensed contractor with a permit and paperwork, a price credit, or more time.
  6. Bind coverage early. A re-inspection after a repair takes days, not hours.

If you are selling an older house

Sellers can take a lot of drama out of this. If your Winter Park or Maitland home is more than 20 years old, think about getting a four-point and wind mitigation report before you list, and gather the permits and invoices for the roof, panel, plumbing and AC. If the report flags something simple, such as a missing relief valve on the water heater or a double-tapped breaker, fixing it before you list usually costs less than negotiating it later under deadline pressure.

Related reading for older-home buyers

Read What an Older Winter Park Home Actually Costs to Own and Buying an Older Winter Park Home This Fall. If the house has a pool, add my Winter Park pool home buyer’s guide. Shopping north of the city? Start with my Maitland homes page.

Want help with an older house?

I have over 37 years in the real estate industry and have been local since 1978. RealTrends ranked me in the top 0.5 percent of Florida agents and #10 in Winter Park by transactions for 2026. If you are looking at an older home in Winter Park or Maitland, call or text me at 407-620-7785 or email will@irlhomes.com. I will help you pull the permits and line up the four-point before it can hold up your closing.


Thinking about selling?

What is your home actually worth?

An online estimate is a starting point, not a price. Send me your address and I’ll put together the recent closed sales near you, the current competition and a price range that holds up with an appraiser, from someone with over 37 years in the Real Estate Industry.

Or ask me a question here and I’ll get back to you the same day.

    Will LaValle

    About the author

    Talk to Will LaValle

    Will LaValle is a REALTOR® with RE/MAX 200 Realty in Winter Park, serving Orlando, Winter Park, Maitland, Longwood, Lake Mary, Windermere, Winter Garden, Sanford and Apopka. Over 37 years in the Real Estate Industry, licensed in Florida since 1989.

    Buying, selling, relocating to Central Florida, or you just want a straight answer on what your home is worth? Reach out directly. No call center, no handoff to an assistant.

    Journal

    More articles