Tax bills went out across Orange and Seminole counties this month, and I am already getting the follow-up question from buyers: “If I buy in Winter Park, Maitland or Lake Mary, what will my bill look like in 2027?” It is a fair question: 2027 is the first tax year under Amendment 3, and most tax pages online still describe the old exemption.
I cannot give you an exact number for a house you have not picked yet. But I can show you how the 2027 bill is built, where the three cities differ, and which official numbers to check before you write an offer.
Step one: the bill starts over when you buy
The single biggest mistake I see is budgeting from the seller’s tax bill. In Florida, the seller’s homestead exemption and their Save Our Homes cap belong to them, not to the house. After a sale, the property appraiser generally reassesses the parcel at market value as of January 1 of the next year. If the sellers have owned a home on Lake Maitland or near Crystal Lake in Lake Mary for twenty years, their bill can be a fraction of yours.
Timing adds a second wrinkle. A purchase in the middle of the year does not change the current year’s bill. The 2026 bill stays in the seller’s name and is based on the seller’s exemptions, and on most Florida contracts the year’s taxes are prorated between buyer and seller at closing. Your first bill based on your price and your exemptions is the following one. So a buyer who closes in spring 2027 typically sees a bill in November 2027 that still reflects the seller’s January 1, 2027 status, and the reset shows up on the 2028 bill.
What Amendment 3 changes on the 2027 roll
The clearest official summary is the Florida Department of Revenue’s Property Tax Oversight bulletin PTO 26-21. According to that bulletin, starting with the 2027 tax roll:
- The homestead exemption for non-school taxes rises to assessed value up to $150,000 in 2027 and up to $250,000 in 2028, with inflation adjustments after that. The school-tax exemption stays at $25,000.
- The annual cap on assessment increases for non-homestead property drops from 10 percent to 5 percent.
- People who were not Florida residents as of December 31, 2026 get a smaller exemption when they qualify, $25,000 for school taxes and up to $50,000 for non-school taxes, and become eligible for the larger exemption beginning with their fifth year of exemption.
Every city tax line is a non-school tax, so the bigger exemption hits the city portion of your bill directly. I explain the December 31 line and the timing questions in Moving to Winter Park After December 31, 2026? The Department says more rules and forms are still coming, so treat any example below as an illustration, not a quote.
The city line: three cities, three rates
Your bill is a stack of separate levies: Orange or Seminole County, the school board, the St. Johns River Water Management District, and others. The city’s line is the one that changes most when you cross a city limit. Here is what each city’s own documents say for fiscal year 2027, which is the year that began October 1, 2026.
Winter Park (Orange County). The City Commission adopted Ordinance 3373-26 on September 23, 2026. It sets 4.0923 mills for operating expenses, a rate the city’s budget materials describe as unchanged for 19 consecutive years, plus 0.1937 mills of voted debt service for the General Obligation Bonds, Series 2017 and 2020. That is 4.2860 mills combined.
Lake Mary (Seminole County). The city’s FY 2027 Adopted Budget is built on 3.5895 mills, which the city manager’s budget message describes as unchanged for the fourteenth consecutive year. It is the lowest of the three, one reason Lake Mary comes up in my Winter Park vs. Lake Mary breakdown.
Maitland (Orange County). Maitland has the most moving parts this year. The city’s FY 2027 budget draft keeps the operating rate at 5.0465 mills, the same as FY 2026. It proposes 0.189 mills for the 2014 general obligation note that paid for the police station, Fire Station 45 and city hall. And it adds something new: 0.289 mills for the 2026 general obligation bonds that voters approved in March 2024 for a new library and improvements to Quinn Strong Park. The draft puts that new levy at about $145 a year on a $500,000 taxable home. Added up, the draft totals 5.5245 mills. City Council’s final millage hearing was scheduled for September 28, 2026, and the adopted FY 2027 budget was not yet posted on the city’s site when I wrote this, so confirm the adopted rates on your TRIM notice or tax bill. My Winter Park vs. Maitland post covers the rest of that comparison.
One example, three cities
To make that concrete, here is the city line only, for a home with $400,000 of taxable value. This is an illustration, not a quote for any address, and it leaves out the county, school and other levies:
- Winter Park: 400 × 4.2860 = about $1,714 a year
- Maitland, using the draft rates: 400 × 5.5245 = about $2,210 a year
- Lake Mary: 400 × 3.5895 = about $1,436 a year
Now add Amendment 3. Say a buyer homesteads a Winter Park house with $600,000 of assessed value in 2027. If that buyer was a Florida resident on December 31, 2026, the non-school exemption can be as much as $150,000, so the city line is figured on about $450,000. If the buyer moved here in 2027, it is up to $50,000, so the city line is figured on about $550,000. At Winter Park’s 4.2860 mills, that $100,000 difference is roughly $429 a year on the city line alone, before the county and other non-school levies. The county and other non-school levies widen the gap. That is not a reason to rush a purchase, but it belongs in the budget.
Second homes work differently. A Park Avenue condo you will not homestead gets no homestead exemption, but once it is on the roll at your price, its assessed value can rise no more than 5 percent a year, down from 10 percent.
First, confirm which city you are actually in
None of these rates matter until you know which ones apply. A 32789 or 32792 Winter Park mailing address can sit in unincorporated Orange County and pay no Winter Park city millage at all. And many Lake Mary addresses, including Heathrow, are in unincorporated Seminole County. I walk through how to check in What a Winter Park Address Actually Means.
The reliable check is the parcel record. Look up the address on the Orange County Property Appraiser or Seminole County Property Appraiser site and note the tax district code. That code determines the combined millage. Use the combined rate the appraiser or tax collector shows for that district, not a total copied from a third-party “tax rate” website.
The November discount is real money
Because bills just arrived, one more local tip. Under section 197.162, Florida Statutes, property taxes paid in November get a 4 percent discount, December 3 percent, January 2 percent and February 1 percent. On a $9,000 bill, paying in November instead of March saves about $360. If you just bought, confirm the bill reached your lender’s escrow account.
My buyer checklist for a 2027 tax estimate
- Pull the parcel record and confirm the county, city and tax district.
- Estimate taxable value from your purchase price, not the seller’s assessed value or bill.
- Apply the exemption you will actually qualify for: the larger one if you were a Florida resident on December 31, 2026, the newcomer one if not.
- Use the combined millage for that tax district from the appraiser or tax collector, and confirm Maitland’s adopted FY 2027 rates.
- File homestead by March 1 with the county where the house sits. The basics are in my Florida Homestead Exemption guide.
- If you are selling a homesteaded house elsewhere in Florida, ask the appraiser about portability. See Downsizing and Florida Homestead Portability.
For Winter Park Electric and city water, read Is Winter Park Expensive?. I am not a tax advisor, so run your situation past a CPA, especially if the December 31 residency date could apply to you.
Want a tax estimate on a specific house?
I have over 37 years in the real estate industry and have been local since 1978. RealTrends ranked me in the top 0.5 percent of Florida agents and #10 in Winter Park by transactions for 2026. If you are weighing Winter Park, Maitland or Lake Mary, call or text me at 407-620-7785 or email will@irlhomes.com. I will pull the parcel, the tax district and a realistic 2027 estimate before you fall in love with the house.
Thinking about selling?
What is your home actually worth?
An online estimate is a starting point, not a price. Send me your address and I’ll put together the recent closed sales near you, the current competition and a price range that holds up with an appraiser, from someone with over 37 years in the Real Estate Industry.
Or ask me a question here and I’ll get back to you the same day.




