Selling an Inherited House in Seminole County: Probate in Sanford, Homestead, and List vs. Sell As-Is

Lake Mary City Hall, Florida

If you inherited a house in Sanford, Longwood, Lake Mary, Oviedo, or anywhere else in Seminole County, the paperwork is only half the problem. The other half is that the house is sitting there with a tax bill, an insurance policy, and a utility account that all still belong to someone who is gone. My statewide guide, How to Sell an Inherited House in Florida, covers the general paths. This post is the Seminole County version: where you actually go, what the county’s own forms ask for, and how I think about listing versus selling as-is.

A note before I start: I am a REALTOR, not an attorney. Probate questions belong with a Florida probate attorney. What I can do is help with pricing, condition, and going to market once someone has legal authority to sell.

Probate in Seminole County is filed in Sanford, but not at the main courthouse

This trips people up. Seminole County probate is handled by the Clerk of the Circuit Court & Comptroller, in the Eighteenth Judicial Circuit. The Clerk’s own website sends probate services to the Juvenile Justice Center at 190 Eslinger Way, Sanford, FL 32773. The main Seminole County Courthouse is next door at 101 Eslinger Way, and the Clerk lists that one for court records, new suits, marriage licenses, and recording. If you walk into the wrong building with a will in your hand, you have lost an hour. The Clerk lists both locations as open Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. (check the Clerk’s site before you drive, since hours and locations can change).

Two other practical points from the Clerk’s materials. The Clerk’s Self Help program supports people representing themselves in formal and summary administration probate cases, and the Clerk posts probate forms and the Eighteenth Circuit checklists on its website. And if the original will is still in a drawer, Florida law requires whoever has it to deliver it to the clerk after the person dies (F.S. 732.901 sets a ten-day window). That is true whether or not anyone ever opens a full case.

The step most heirs do not know about: the homestead petition

Here is the part that matters most for a sale. If the person who died lived in the house as their Florida homestead, that house does not automatically behave like any other asset. Florida’s constitution (Article X, Section 4) limits who can inherit a homestead and shields it from the decedent’s creditors in certain situations. To get a clear answer on who the title actually passed to, the personal representative or an heir typically asks the court for an order determining homestead status. The procedure is Florida Probate Rule 5.405.

The Seminole County Clerk publishes its own form for this, a Petition to Determine Homestead Status of Real Property, in a version for estates with a will. Reading it is useful even if an attorney files it, because it shows you exactly what the court wants to know. It asks for:

  • The physical address and the parcel ID of the property
  • The full legal description
  • Whether the property sits inside or outside a municipality, and how many contiguous acres it covers
  • Whether the decedent left a spouse, minor children, or other devisees
  • What the will says about the house, and who the petitioner believes the title passed to
  • The names and addresses of everyone else with an interest, including unpaid creditors

Why I care as the listing agent: a buyer’s title company will want clean proof of who can sign the deed. If that order is still pending, I can usually still prepare the house and the pricing, but I will not promise a closing date until the attorney tells me where the title stands.

What the Seminole County Property Appraiser can tell you in ten minutes

Before you decide anything, pull the parcel on the Seminole County Property Appraiser’s site. You are looking for four things:

  • Owner of record. It will usually still show the person who died until a deed or court order is recorded.
  • Homestead flag. This tells you whether the exemption was in place, which matters for the petition above.
  • Just value versus assessed value. Long-time homesteaded owners often have an assessed value far below market, thanks to the Save Our Homes cap.
  • Sale history. It shows when the house last traded and for how much.

That gap between assessed and just value is the one that surprises families. The homestead exemption and the cap belong to the owner who lived there. Once the house sells, the new owner’s assessed value generally resets toward market value, so the seller’s tax bill is a poor guide to what a buyer will pay. Buyers in Lake Mary and Oviedo understand that. Do not let the old bill drive your pricing, or your pitch.

Also watch the calendar. Florida property tax bills go out around November 1 and are due by March 31, with a discount for paying early (4 percent in November, stepping down each month). Exemptions are set as of January 1. If the owner died in 2026 and the house is still in the estate on January 1, 2027, ask your attorney and the Property Appraiser how the homestead exemption is treated going forward, because the 2027 bill may look very different from the one you are used to.

List it or sell it as-is? How I actually think about it

Search for this topic and you will find plenty of cash-buyer pages promising a fast, simple sale. Sometimes that is the right answer. Often it is not, and the difference comes down to the house. Here is how I walk heirs through it:

  • Condition. A 1980s Sanford or Longwood ranch with its original roof, original panel, and a kitchen no one has touched in 30 years is a different decision than a clean, updated house that only needs the personal belongings removed. The more work the house needs, the more an as-is sale makes sense.
  • Time. Every month you hold the house, the estate pays taxes, insurance, and utilities, and keeps the lawn and the pool from becoming a problem with the city or the HOA. Vacant houses can also run into insurance coverage limits, so tell the carrier the house is empty.
  • Buyer type. A financed buyer wants a house that passes appraisal and inspection. A cash or investor buyer will take on repairs but will price that in. I can show you both versions of the number.
  • Net, not headline. Compare what the estate would keep after repairs, commissions, closing costs, and carrying costs on each path. The highest offer is not always the best net.

When I price an inherited house, I start with Stellar MLS solds for similar homes in the same neighborhood, then adjust for condition, because condition is where most of the spread between an as-is sale and a market-ready one comes from. I will not quote you a number in a blog post, because a number without the house in front of me is a guess. If you want, I will walk it, tell you what is worth fixing and what is not, and put both paths on paper.

A simple order of operations

  1. Talk to a Florida probate attorney first. Ask specifically whether a homestead determination is needed and how long it is likely to take.
  2. Find the original will and deliver it to the Clerk if you have not already.
  3. Pull the parcel on the Property Appraiser’s site and confirm the owner of record, homestead flag, and values.
  4. Secure the house: change the locks if needed, tell the insurance carrier about the vacancy, and keep utilities on.
  5. Have me walk the house for a pricing and condition review. That costs you nothing and does not commit you to a sale.
  6. Decide on list versus as-is once you know the legal timeline, the repair list, and the net on each path.

If your house is near the county line, double-check which county you are in. A Winter Park mailing address does not always mean Orange County, and I explain why in What a Winter Park Address Actually Means. If you are weighing the tax side of the next owner’s decision, my post on Amendment 3 and the homestead exemption covers what changes in 2027.

Talk to me before you decide

I have been in real estate for over 37 years and local since 1978. RealTrends ranked me in the top 0.5 percent of Florida agents, and I am #10 in Winter Park. If you have inherited a house in Seminole County and are not sure where to start, call or text me at 407-620-7785 or email will@irlhomes.com. I will tell you honestly what the house is worth, what it needs, and which route makes sense. If you want a starting point on value, try my home value page.


Thinking about selling?

What is your home actually worth?

An online estimate is a starting point, not a price. Send me your address and I’ll put together the recent closed sales near you, the current competition and a price range that holds up with an appraiser, from someone with over 37 years in the Real Estate Industry.

Or ask me a question here and I’ll get back to you the same day.

    Will LaValle

    About the author

    Talk to Will LaValle

    Will LaValle is a REALTOR® with RE/MAX 200 Realty in Winter Park, serving Orlando, Winter Park, Maitland, Longwood, Lake Mary, Windermere, Winter Garden, Sanford and Apopka. Over 37 years in the Real Estate Industry, licensed in Florida since 1989.

    Buying, selling, relocating to Central Florida, or you just want a straight answer on what your home is worth? Reach out directly. No call center, no handoff to an assistant.

    Journal

    More articles